|
|
|
Windows Secrets Newsletter • Issue 123 • 2007-09-20 • Circulation: over 270,000 |
|
Contents INTRODUCTION: New faces bring you more Windows info TOP STORY: Protect yourself from silent Windows updates KNOWN ISSUES: Readers state concerns over Windows Update WACKY WEB WEEK: Vista developers invent wild user interface WOODY'S WINDOWS: Improve on Windows Explorer with Xplorer² PERIMETER SCAN: The best way to scan for rootkits YOUR SUBSCRIPTION: How to change your address or unsubscribe |
|
For links to every topic in this issue, scroll down to the
Index |
|
ADS
|
|
INTRODUCTION New faces bring you more Windows info
By
Brian Livingston
You're starting to see some new bylines in the newsletter, and I'm happy as a bug in a rug to be getting some help around this place. Our new managing editor is Virginia Culler. She was previously employed by Aditi Technologies of Redmond, Wash., where she worked as a contractor for large high-tech firms. Prior to that, Virginia was a technical writer in Seattle for Milliman Global. She graduated with a degree in linguistics from Bryn Mawr College. Recently added to our team is editorial assistant Diane Korngiebel. She studied at the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University and has been an adjunct professor of history at the University of Arizona, Wabash College, and the University of Central Arkansas. Diane wrote the Known Issues column on Sept. 13 and helped put together this week's as well. Keep watching, and we'll have even more changes in the newsletter in the next few weeks! Brian Livingston is editorial director of WindowsSecrets.com and the co-author of Windows Vista Secrets and 10 other books. |
|
ADS
|
|
TOP STORY Protect yourself from silent Windows updates
Microsoft acknowledges the lack of notice In my Sept. 13 article, I reported that Windows Update (WU) has been silently installing nine small executable files on Windows XP and Vista, despite the fact that users had disabled auto-installation. The files that WU has overwritten to date consist of benign support files — but many Windows users expressed outrage that any process was installing files without notification. Reaction from Microsoft to the article was almost immediate. In a post the same day on the Microsoft Update Product Team Blog, program manager Nate Clinton confirmed that updates to Windows Update itself are performed without notifying users. This is true even if users specify Let me choose when to install them or Notify me but don't automatically download or install (two of the four options available to users). In his statement, Clinton acknowledged that the silent file writes are not what users expect after they disable automatic installs:
One of the first test centers to independently confirm WU's silent installs was eWeek Labs. An eWeek analyst, Andrew Garcia, published a blog entry on Sept. 13 documenting the logs of two test machines that had been set to Notify but do not install updates. According to Garcia, even though one of the PCs hadn't been touched in months, both machines showed evidence that version 7.0.6000.381 of the files had been installed in August. The lab had acted at the request of eWeek's Microsoft Watch columnist Joe Wilcox, one of several journalists who picked up on a press release issued by Windows Secrets publicist Revell-Pechar Inc. In a series of three blog posts, Wilcox wrote that nothing in the Windows Update Privacy Statement gives Microsoft "permission to update without user consent" (Sept. 12); that "the silent downloads also raise questions about ownership" of users' PCs (Sept. 13); and that Microsoft was using the existence of its employees' blog posts "to avoid answering tough questions the news media might ask about privacy and Windows Update" (Sept. 14). One blog, Nynaeve, recounted yet another downside to the silent updates. The patching process had awakened the blogger's portable computer from standby mode at 3:00 a.m. while stored in an insulated laptop bag. Because the update process failed to put the computer back into standby after the installation, the laptop's battery was exhausted by the time the writer discovered the problem later that day. Furthermore, the fact that the computer was running in a bag for so long could damage the machine and might even pose a fire hazard. To say this story has sparked controversy would be an understatement. The comments flying around the Web vary from outrage to the exact opposite position: that Microsoft is completely right to install WU support files, regardless of the user's Automatic Updates preferences. One account, in the Handler's Diary blog, said there was no cause for concern since the Turn off Automatic Updates setting in the Automatic Updates control panel prevents the silent updates from occurring. (This is true, although it generates repeated boot-up warnings, as described below. Some readers incorrectly inferred from my article that even this setting allows stealthy updates; it does not.) Perhaps the situation is best summed up by reporter Todd Bishop, who wrote in a Seattle Post-Intelligencer article:
It's important to note that there is no reason to remove or roll back the updated support files that Windows Update may have installed on a PC. There's no evidence that these files are harmful or cause any software conflicts. Furthermore, if you use a corporate patch management solution, such as Microsoft's WSUS (Windows Server Update Services), you circumvent Windows Update and no files will be installed by WU. But if you're an individual or a small business using Windows Update (or its enhanced sibling, Microsoft Update), you may be concerned about Microsoft installing patches before you've had a chance to research their reliability. In that case, you can completely turn off the Automatic Updates Agent, thereby preventing updates or even notifications from occurring. If you take this step, you'll become solely responsible for learning about new Microsoft patches yourself. I'll explain below how to adapt to this situation. In the meantime, here's how to turn off Automatic Updates and prevent stealth installs: In Windows XP, take these steps: Step 1. Open Control Panel and launch Automatic Updates (in the Security Center category). Step 2. Select Turn off Automatic Updates. Click OK. In Windows Vista, take these steps: Step 1. Open Control Panel and launch Windows Update (in the System and Maintenance category). Step 2. In the left pane, click Change settings. Step 3. Click Never check for updates (not recommended). Click OK. Step 4. Click Continue, if prompted by User Account Control. With Automatic Updates turned off, Windows Update will still update itself (and notify you of patches), but only when you manually launch Windows Update and give your consent. What to do about repeated boot-up warnings Turning off Automatic Updates can cause Windows Security Alert pop-up balloons to appear in the taskbar tray every time you log on. (See Figure 1.) ![]() Figure 1. Turning off Automatic Updates causes scary error balloons featuring a red shield. If this bothers you, Windows XP allows you to suppress any warnings that relate to Automatic Updates. You can also do this in Vista but, unfortunately, the newer OS forces you to turn off all security alerts just to suppress the Automatic Updates warnings. To eliminate the warning balloons about Automatic Updates in both XP and Vista, take these steps: Step 1. Double-click the red shield icon in the taskbar, or open the Control Panel and launch the Security Center. Step 2. In the left pane or box, click Change the way Security Center alerts me. Step 3. In XP, uncheck Automatic Updates and click OK. In Vista, select the second or third option. Use Secunia's Software Inspector to check for updates With the Windows Update Agent turned off, how will you know if you have the latest security patches and updates you need? First, read the Windows Secrets Newsletter that comes out two days after Patch Tuesday. Look in our paid section for descriptions of any patches that are reported to have negative side-effects, and use our recommended workarounds if any problems might affect you. (How to get the paid version.) Then, to check for needed updates to Windows and dozens of other programs, use the Secunia Software Inspector. This free service was described in the Aug. 16 and Sept. 6 issues of Windows Secrets. Once you know what updates you need, you can visit the Microsoft Update Web site, which offers updates for both Windows and Microsoft Office. The Secunia report includes a link to Microsoft's site and other update sites so you don't even have to bookmark them. Users don't expect Microsoft to be perfect. But because of the company's very human mistakes with some previous updates, many customers understandably want to do their homework before installing every patch Microsoft offers. If the company's own software settings can't be trusted to provide that level of control, users will continue to seek alternatives. Have a tip about Windows? Readers receive a gift certificate for a book, CD, or DVD of their choice for sending tips we printed. Send us your tips via the Windows Secrets contact page. Scott Dunn is associate editor of the Windows Secrets Newsletter. He has been a contributing editor of PC World since 1992 and currently writes for the magazine's Here's How section. |
|
KNOWN ISSUES Readers state concerns over Windows Update
Stability issues raised in update's wake The Sept. 13 issue of Windows Secrets revealed that Windows Update has been installing some files silently, despite the fact that users have selected a "do not install" option in the Automatic Updates control panel. Many readers wondered why their firewalls did not bar Microsoft's activity. The answer is that the Windows Update Agent initiated the contact to Microsoft's servers. The resulting file download, therefore, appeared to be an expected response. Other readers asked if they could — or should — configure their firewalls to reject Microsoft downloads. A reader named Scott W. writes:
First, there would always be new IP servers that would need to be added to the blockade. An extensive list of entries recently provided in the KezNews forum can give you an idea of how long your table might become — unless you want to use wildcards to block anything originating from the Microsoft domain. Second, the burden would fall squarely on the end user to determine what needed to be blocked and what didn't. This is far too labor-intensive a solution for most companies, and it may cause unforeseen problems. If you're really concerned, an easier workaround that simply involves clicking Turn off Automatic Updates is provided in this issue's Top Story. Microsoft disregards its own definitions Rob Harmer pointed out that Windows Update's stealthy behavior was in breach of Microsoft's own Aero User Experience Guidelines for Privacy and Security (produced by the Microsoft User Experience Group in October 2003). The policy states:
The EULA does not confer carte blanche Some readers believe that the Windows EULA (End User License Agreement) allows Microsoft to apply updates at will. An anonymous reader writes:
The EULA for Windows XP Pro states:
Furthermore, regardless of what the EULA may theoretically allow, this is a matter of trust. If a majority of users believe they have set their permissions in the Automatic Updates control panel to prevent certain actions, then Microsoft should respect those preferences. At the very least, Microsoft should notify users in clear, unambiguous language of any changes that may be needed. The notification should also include a link to a Knowledge Base article so users can make informed decisions. The silent installs by Windows Update have no KB article explaining them. Use Firefox but report IE 7 as your browser In the Sept. 13 Known Issues column, a reader suggested installing IE Tab, an add-on that lets you run Windows Update from within Firefox. (WU normally requires IE.) But other readers said this approach is no different from running IE 7, including all of its vulnerabilities. Reader Richard Carter recommends what he considers a better alternative to IE Tab:
Various people in our office tested User Agent Switcher with Windows Update and its sibling, Microsoft Update (which also upgrades MS Office apps). It worked just fine with both Firefox 2.0.0.6 and the recently released 2.0.0.7. To install User Agent Switcher, go to the Firefox add-ons site. Click Install Now. The installer will restart Firefox when finished or prompt you to do so before the changes will take effect. To add the User Agent Switcher button to your Firefox toolbar, right-click the toolbar and choose Customize. Drag the User Agent icon to where you want it. When selected, it offers a drop-down menu from which you can choose the browser you want to report. Readers Harmer, Kitt, Scott W., and Carter will each receive a gift certificate for a book, CD, or DVD of their choice for sending tips we printed. Send us your tips via the Windows Secrets contact page. The Known Issues column brings you readers' comments on our recent articles. Virginia Culler is managing editor of WindowsSecrets.com. Editorial assistant Diane Korngiebel contributed to this article. |
|
EDITOR'S BOOKSHELF
|
|
WACKY WEB WEEK Vista developers invent wild user interface
|
|
YOUR SUBSCRIPTION The Windows Secrets Newsletter is published weekly on the 1st through 4th Thursdays of each month, plus occasional news updates. We skip an issue on the 5th Thursday of any month, plus the week of Thanksgiving and the last two weeks of August and December. Publisher: WindowsSecrets.com LLC, Attn: #120 Editor, 1700 7th Ave., Suite 116, Seattle, WA 98101-1323 USA. Vendors, please send no unsolicited packages to this address (readers' letters are fine). Editorial Director: Brian Livingston. Editor-at-Large: Fred Langa. Associate Editor: Scott Dunn. Contributing Editors: Susan Bradley, Mark Edwards, Woody Leonhard, Ryan Russell. Research Director: Vickie Stevens. Program Director: Brent Scheffler. Managing Editor: Virginia Culler. Editorial Assistant: Diane Korngiebel. Trademarks: Microsoft and Windows are registered trademarks of Microsoft Corporation. The Windows Secrets series of books is published by Wiley Publishing Inc. The Windows Secrets Newsletter, WindowsSecrets.com, LangaList, LangaList Plus, WinFind, Security Baseline, Patch Watch, Perimeter Scan, Wacky Web Week, the Logo Design (W, S or road, and Star), and the slogan Everything Microsoft Forgot to Mention all are trademarks and service marks of WindowsSecrets.com LLC. All other marks are the trademarks or service marks of their respective owners. HOW TO SUBSCRIBE: Anyone may subscribe to this newsletter by visiting our free signup page. WE GUARANTEE YOUR PRIVACY: 1. We will never sell, rent, or give away your address to any outside party, ever. 2. We will never send you any unrequested e-mail, besides newsletter updates. 3. All unsubscribe requests are honored immediately, period. Privacy policy HOW TO UNSUBSCRIBE: To unsubscribe from the Windows Secrets Newsletter,
|